Posted in communication, Human Resources, leadership, policy, social media, technology

Social media – be careful what you post for

This post from our contributor and legal specialist, Veale Wasbrough Vizards, explores how a solid Social Media Policy can help your school succeed in claims brought to the Employment Appeal Tribunal, using a recent high profile case as an example.

The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) has recently upheld a decision ruling that a dismissal for derogatory comments about an employer on Facebook was fair.

In British Waterways Board v Smith, Mr Smith was employed by the British Waterways Board (BW) as a manual worker for 8 years. As part of his job, Mr Smith worked on a rota where he was on standby for one week in every five. BW prohibited employees drinking alcohol when they were on standby. It also had a social media policy which forbade ‘any action on the internet which might embarrass or discredit BW’.

During the investigation of a grievance raised by Mr Smith, Mr Smith’s manager supplied HR with copies of pages from Mr Smith’s Facebook account which included derogatory comments by Mr Smith about his supervisors. On receipt, the HR team investigated further and identified evidence that suggested Mr Smith was drunk whilst on standby.

A disciplinary investigation subsequently took place and several other Facebook comments were identified which were either derogatory about BW, supervisors and colleagues, or suggested that Mr Smith had been drinking on days when on standby.

Mr Smith’s manager was aware of some of the comments and had previously raised them with HR (although he had not sent screenshots). HR had not investigated at the time because they were “too busy”. Mr Smith accepted that he made the comments but said that they were just ‘banter’ and he had not in fact been drinking. He also contended that his Facebook account had been hacked and changed from ‘private’ to ‘public’.

At a subsequent disciplinary hearing, the decision-maker concluded that, irrespective of whether the comments were true, they had the potential to undermine confidence in Mr Smith’s ability to react in an emergency and left BW open to public condemnation. It was also decided that Mr Smith’s actions were a clear breach of BW’s policies and he was summarily dismissed for gross misconduct.

Mr Smith brought a claim for unfair dismissal to the Employment Tribunal (ET).

The ET found that, although the process BW followed was fair, the decision to dismiss Mr Smith was not within the band of reasonable responses which a reasonable employer would take and therefore was not fair. In particular, the ET found that BW failed to
consider Mr Smith’s points of mitigation.

Overturning this decision on appeal, the EAT found that, as the ET
accepted that a fair procedure had been followed, it must have concluded that BW had considered Mr Smith’s points of mitigation. That being so, the ET had improperly substituted its own views for that of the employer. It held that the decision to dismiss was fair.

Best practice

The very public nature of comments on social media means that the potential for reputational damage is significant. What assisted BW in this case was having very clear policies addressing the use of social media and being clear with employees about what is and is not acceptable − a practice we would always recommend. Those schools which have adopted our template employment documentation will be familiar with the operation of our Social Media Policy.

This case also highlights the importance of identifying and considering all points of mitigation when deciding on disciplinary action.

Whilst BW was able to demonstrate that the dismissal was fair in this case, even though it had been aware of (albeit had not investigated) the Facebook comments for a number of years, it would be best practice to avoid delay in investigating concerns which come to your school’s attention – not least in cases involving comments on social media, to avoid the potential for further reputational damage.

For more information, please contact Alice Reeve on 0117 314 5383.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s